Friday, November 6, 2009

Unit 4 Plagiarism Topic

So... Don't get me wrong, I am all about giving people credit where credit is due. If you came up with the idea, I definitely want to make sure other people know it was yours and know where to find what all you said about it. But... I have always had a hard time with the definition, or lack of definition for what is considered "common knowledge". That has always been the tricky area for me. Especially in the age of the internet where you can research one topic on a hundred sites in minutes, it can become sticky trying to keep straight what came from where and what just came from your own brain. When you think about it, absolutely everything you know you learned from somewhere... So at what point does it become your own knowledge? After you have known it for a day? A week? Month? Or maybe just once you don't know where you learned it? But even then it should be cited if it came from somewhere right? Even if you don't remember where? And what if a dozen different sources are giving you the same information? Does that make it common knowledge? Or do you just have to pick one to cite? What if you are putting pieces from all those sites together to form your thoughts? Then are they really your thoughts or do you have to cite all the sources that provided the pieces to your mental puzzle? I understand that there are some things that are obvious one way or the other. The sun is hot, that is common knowledge, specific quotes or statistics must be cited. But what about everything in between?

3 comments:

  1. Lyndsay-
    I understand exactly where you are coming from! Common knowledge is different for everyone because not everyone have done the same exact things in the same way or at the same time. I guess the only thing to do is to ask Cassie what are our guidelines.. I know in a sense it seems a bit juvenile but in order to get the grade we have to ask specifics... I use to keep flashcards and when I find a good source I write the reference then I write the points of my reference that I want to use so everything is sorted and neat.. Color codes help in differentiating between a book, article, or a website reference. I hope this helps..

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hey Lyndsay
    Wow you said exactly how I feel about all this plagairism ( can't spell it at moment lol)They make so much fuss over it here that we don't dare cite everything. But what a pain indeed and keeping track of each little sentence you may have grabbed from this article or that one. You read my mind exactly with all you said on this subject! So I say Ditto to everything Lyndsay stated above.
    Doreen

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thank you both for your support! I'm glad to know I'm not the only one that thinks this is a little fuzzy or gray... Mandy, I'm with you... At this point it's about getting the grade and not losing points for something I could have fixed... Good luck to you both and thanks again!

    ReplyDelete